cjc

Church proposals anger Jewish body

The Okanagan Saturday
By: J. P. Squire
Church proposals anger Jewish body; United Church delegates set to debate resolutions targeting Israel at general meeting Okanagan Saturday

Members of the Canadian Jewish Congress accused United Church members of anti-Semitism Friday on the eve of the church’s 40th general council meeting in Kelowna.

CJC representatives will attend the conference, which starts Sunday, to express concern about perceived anti-Israel proposals submitted for debate and to urge the 400 delegates to defeat the resolutions.

“The resolutions are one-sided, inflammatory and, in supporting a boycott of Israel, align the UCC with the enemies of Israel seeking its destruction,” said Bernie M. Farber, the CJC’s CEO.

He will be among CJC representatives on hand to ensure UCC delegates understand the harmful nature of the resolutions to the Jewish-UCC relationship.

They call on the United Church, Canada’s largest Protestant denomination, “to advocate a comprehensive boycott of Israeli academic and cultural institutions.” Another urges the church to “support the international campaign of boycott . . .

divestment and sanctions until Israel meets its obligation to recognize the Palestinian people’s inalienable right to self-determination.” “Of greater concern than the proposals themselves are the supporting materials, which constitute a direct assault on Canadian Jews, echoing classical anti-Semitic canards of dual loyalty and political manipulation,” said Farber in a news release.

The supporting materials castigate Canadian MPs who have “accepted sponsored trips to Israel, which might be called bribes,” and who are “affiliated with the State of Israel” or “are dual citizens with Israel and have sensitive roles in Canada.” “CJC and the United Church of Canada have worked assiduously toward rapprochement over the past several years, largely through the Canadian Christian-Jewish consultation,” added former CJC co-president Rabbi Reuven Bulka, who will also be in Kelowna.

“It is discouraging and frustrating to see all of this important effort imperiled by these resolutions and their supporting documents,” Bulka said. “If passed, these proposals will do irreparable harm to future relations, not only between our organizations, but also to dialogue between our communities.” UCC moderator Rev. David Giuliano acknowledged the proposals are controversial, but said: “We’re a church that debates these things in the open, and while some people may have put a proposal forward, it by no means says at this point that it is endorsed by the national church.” The war of words began last week with an op-ed piece submitted by the CJC to the National Post about four resolutions criticizing Israel’s treatment of Palestinians.

In his own op-ed piece, Giuliano responded: “The four proposals in question are among (173) proposals relating to many different issues that are coming to the council from regional conferences of the church. They are what they are — proposals that will be debated, likely amended and either approved or defeated.” Conference organizers also circulated a submission from the CJC to delegates, he noted.

“As we have done in recent meetings of general council, we will also welcome a rabbi and an imam to this council as invited guests who have full speaking and participation privileges, but not a vote.” Based on years of dialogue, the UCC knows proposals such as those “do cause pain and hurt to Jewish people in Canada,” Giuliano acknowledged, adding: “Most of the world’s states, including Canada, stood by and did little, or worse” during the Holocaust.

In 2003, the UCC affirmed that peace in the Middle East would require the recognition by Palestine and other neighbouring Arab states of Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state within safe and secure borders, he said.

“At the same time, the United Church’s general councils have sought to remind Canadians of the existence of Palestinian people, their struggles and despair and their desire for a safe and secure homeland.

“The United Church, in concert with most of the world, has challenged Israel to recognize the damage that the continued occupation of Palestinian territories does to itself, Palestinians and the potential for lasting peace.”